Pit Boss Brisket Cooking Too Fast? What Happens, Plus Tips To Cook The Perfect Brisket on Pit Boss Pellet Grill

Slab of brisket meat, what happens if you cook brisket too fast, Pit Boss brisket cooking too fast - The Barbecue Grill

Most people agree that the best way to prepare brisket is to slow cook it in an oven or by a smoker.

Slow cooking allows the fat underneath the meat to melt away and leave you with tender, moist meat – it’s a widely accepted method among pit masters and home cooks.

When smoking any meat on a Pit Boss Pellet Grill or in this case, the beef brisket, it’s essential to cook the Pit Boss brisket at the right temperature. Cooking at a low temperature, around 225°F, is key because it is important to keep the meat’s juicy flavor and tender texture.

But if you cook too fast, it can become tough and dry. However, there are circumstances when you require to prepare a brisket quickly. So what happens if you cook brisket too fast?

Read on to find out what happens when you cook brisket too fast, how you can make sure you don’t do it again, and get some great ideas for how best to cook flavorful brisket, whatever your preferred smoked brisket method.

What Is A Brisket?

A cut of beef from a cow’s chest is called brisket. It comes from the “first cut” of the beef carcass, specifically the animal’s breastplate or pectoral area.

The brisket comes from the German word “brüst,” which refers to breast or chest.

Diagram of different cuts of beef - What happens if you cook brisket too fast, Pit Boss brisket cooking too fast - The Barbecue Grill

This cut is particularly rich in collagen—the proteins that give its unctuousness and ability to break down over time when simmered and low-and-slow with smoke, heat, and moisture. 

Brisket also has some fat on it, which is good. Fats like tallow (beef fat) render beautifully into an unctuous gravy, that absorbs all those luscious spices we will add. 

Brisket is a very flavorful piece of meat, not because it has been salted or injected with anything, but because that is just how brisket tastes!

It’s neutral and adaptable in any recipe you want to make, whether it involves Asian flavors and sriracha or traditional American barbeque sauce and whiskey.

Read More >> Pit Boss 700FB Review

How to Choose The Proper Brisket

When selecting a brisket, choose one that is fatty, which is the point cut. The fat will preserve the meat moist and flavorful as it cooks, and you will get tender brisket as a result.

Alternatively, if you are a fan of lean meat or more meat you could opt for a flat cut but there’s less flavor in that section.

Cut the excess fat before cooking brisket. To keep the meat moist and add taste, leave about 1/4 inch of fat on it.

The shape of the brisket is roughly rectangular, with a slightly tapered bottom that narrows to a small pointed end. The size will depend on the animal it comes from, but they are generally large cuts weighing between 12 and 20 pounds.

Always go for the full packer brisket. This is because with the full packer brisket, you can get a better quality smoked brisket instead of smaller cut brisket.

What Happens If You Cook Brisket Too Fast? Why Should You Slow Cook Brisket?

When cooking on a pellet grill, it’s important to ensure that the internal temperature doesn’t reach too high. If it happens, the meat can end up being hard and dry. Additionally, it can become tough and dry if you don’t cook it at a low temperature.

This is because when meat cooks faster than normal, the meat fibers loosen and heat up, causing them to tighten up and form a tight bond with the cooking surface.

That’s why it seems like it was cooked for a long time when you overcook the meat, similar to the chicken meat condition called woody breast syndrome.

You can avoid this by allowing the tough fibers to break down and become more tender. So when cooking your brisket on a Pit Boss pellet grill, make sure you cook it at a slow and steady pace so that the fibers don’t get too loose and tighten up. It’s necessary to grill the brisket at a low temperature of about 225°F. 

A good rule to stick by when handling brisket is to add one hour to the slow cooking per pound of brisket, for instance, a 3-pound beef brisket will require about 3 hours of slow cooking time.

Read More >> Rec Tec vs Pit Boss: The Ultimate Grilling Battle

The Best Way to Prep The Pit Boss Brisket for Smoking

While smoking is one of the easiest ways to cook a brisket, it’s also one of the most critical steps.

Before you can begin cooking, you need to allow your meat to rest after removing it from the refrigerator. As a result, the meat might become softer and form a lovely crust on the outside.

Photo of smoked brisket - What happens if you cook brisket too fast, Pit Boss brisket cooking too fast - The Barbecue Grill

Firstly, remove most of the fat from the outside of the brisket. Then, season both sides with a dry rub.

If you want a spicy rub with various spices such as cumin, go for itBe sure to carefully follow your brisket rub packet’s instructions and adjust according to taste. The meat will gain taste and moisture.

Next, place the meat in a large bowl, cover it with plastic wrap, and place it in the refrigerator to let the brisket rest and allow the flavors to infuse overnight.

Tips to Smoke A Brisket

It’s important to keep the meat moist and flavorful, so you must preheat the smoker to 225°F and pat it dry with paper towels before putting it in the smoker. Grill your brisket until the internal temperature hits 195°F

The brisket should be reheated in the Pit Boss pellet smoker until it reaches 205°F. Cook the meat for 1-2 hours in the aluminum foil (or pink butcher paper if that’s what you prefer), then remove and serve it.

After the meat has finished cooking, you can keep it wrapped in foil for at least an hour to lock in moisture and flavor. 

How To Smoke A Beef Brisket On Pit Boss Pellet Grill?

There is no easier or better way to cook a brisket than on a Pit Boss pellet grill! These grills are designed specifically for low and slow meat smoking, making them the perfect companion to cooking delicious beef.

Step 1: Start trimming excess fat cap from your brisket before placing it on the Pit Boss grills. It makes your meat juicy.

Step 2: Set your Pit Boss to 225 °F and with your brisket wrapped, smoke brisket for 6 to 8 hours until the brisket internal temperature reaches 165 °F. After it reaches 165°F, remove it from the smoker and Cover with Roll peach butcher paper (this is our Best Recommended Pink Butcher Paper Roll) into a leakproof seal, then place it back in the smoker seam-side down for an additional 3–4 hours, or until it hits 200°F. Spraying the meat with beef broth every two hours will help keep it moist.

Step 3: When your smoked brisket meat is fork-tender, slice and serve it with your favorite barbecue sauce. The Pit Boss smoker ensures that your meat is delicious and perfectly cooked.

Smoking Brisket at 250°F vs 225°F

If you smoke brisket Pit Boss at 225°F, it would be more tender and juicy. If you smoke brisket Pit Boss at 250°F, it would be drier but will still taste delicious.

Some say low and slow smoking process is the only way to go, while others say smoked brisket on a Pit Boss can be cooked much higher.

However, below is a general Pit Boss brisket recipe I use to cook at 250°F to get the meat tender and juicy, with the smoked beef brisket recipe ideas inspired by Amazingribs.com.

Read More >> How To Clean Pit Boss Grill?

Easy Smoked Brisket Recipe


  • 1 beef brisket (5-7 pounds)
  • Dry rub of your choice (i.e. Kosher salt and pepper mixture, Worcestershire sauce, etc)
  • BBQ sauce of your choice


Slabs of brisket meat for smoking brisket - What happens if you cook brisket too fast, Pit Boss brisket cooking too fast - The Barbecue Grill
  1. Trim the fat cap from the beef.
  2. Apply a dry rub to all sides of the beef.
  3. Preheat your grill to 225 degrees Fahrenheit.
  4. It should be placed on the grill and smoked for 1 hour per pound or until it reaches 195 degrees Fahrenheit internally.
  5. Cover it in aluminum foil and grill it until the meat reaches 205 °F.
  6. 30 minutes should pass after removing the food from the grill.
  7. Serve with barbecue sauce after slicing it against the grain. Enjoy!

Read More >> Best Wifi Pellet Grills


Now that you know what happens if you cook brisket too fast and how you can make the perfect brisket for your meal, you are well on your way to cook the best Pit Boss Brisket with more confidence!

To prevent overcooking the brisket, it is best to use a meat thermometer to track the internal meat temperature and determine when the meat is cooked. You don’t want it to become rigid and dry, and lose all its moisture and flavor when it is cooked too quickly.

The USDA recommends 165°F for whole meats like brisket. You can also touch your beef to find the right texture. It should have a firm but not stiff feel to the touch.

It is also essential to ensure that your smoker’s temperature stays constant so that the meat doesn’t overcook or dry out.

That said, enjoy the cooking process!


What happens if you cook brisket too fast on Pit Boss Pellet Grill?

If you cook brisket too fast On Pit Boss Pellet Grill, the outside of the meat will be overcooked and dry while the inside will be undercooked and tough. It is essential to cook slowly and evenly to ensure the best brisket texture and flavor.

Can brisket be cooked fast?

Yes, brisket can be cooked fast, as quick as 5 to 6 hours, through a method called hot and fast cooking.

What should I do if my brisket is overcooked?

If your Brisket is overcooked, you can try to salvage it by slicing off the overcooked parts and eating only the more rare inner sections of the meat.

Alternatively, if it is already overcooked, add 1 – 2 cups of beef stock, water, or beer to the pot and bring it to a boil. After that, turn off the heat and give the food 30 to 45 minutes to rest in the liquid.

What should I do if my brisket is undercooked instead?

If your beef brisket is undercooked, you will need to cook it for longer until it reaches the internal temperature of 200°F. Just be careful to check the temperature frequently to avoid overcooking the meat in the process.

Read More >> The Best Pellet Grill For Searing Steaks

How to smoke a corned beef brisket on a pellet grill?

The key to smoking a corned beef brisket on a pellet grill is patience and low temperatures. Briskets are fatty and have lots of connective tissue, so if you try to smoke them at high temperatures, they’ll become dry and chewy.

How long does it take to smoke a beef brisket on a Pit Boss?

That depends on a few factors, but for the most part, it can take anywhere from 10-14 hours. 

What is the best way to slice brisket?

Brisket is a cut of meat from the front of the cattle’s chest, supporting the head and capable of movement. Although it is a muscle, it is very tender, making it difficult to slice without some skill.

There are two ways to slice it; thin slices with a sharp knife or thick slices with a large knife:-

  • Thin slice: You reach the fat layer underneath the brisket after slicing through meat and connective tissue. You can avoid seeing this layer and throwing off your slice by following one of these methods:

1. Slice across the grain, running thin lines through the brisket. If slicing is done correctly, you will see thin strands running across your slice.

2. Slice into thin pieces, which will make it easier to cut through the fat layer.

3. Turn it so you are slicing parallel to the grain before you begin cutting thin slices through fat layers. This will improve your grip and attack angle for your cut.

  • Thick slice: Since fat is better left uneaten in brisket, cutting can be done on either side of the fat layer for thicker slices that are still edible if cooked properly. Briskets have little danger of botox, so don’t be afraid to use a somewhat dull knife for your thick slices.

What can I do with leftover brisket?

Brisket has the advantage of being versatile and can be used for almost anything, even if it’s leftover smoked brisket:

  • Slice it up and eat it in a sandwich.
  • Dice it up and add it to your chili, soup, or casserole.
  • Use the cooked meat to make tacos, nachos, or quesadillas.
  • Add brisket to your favorite casserole, giving it a flavor boost.

What is the best way to store leftover brisket?

Full packer brisket meat on chopping board - What happens if you cook brisket too fast, Pit Boss brisket cooking too fast - The Barbecue Grill

The best way to store leftover brisket depends on how soon you plan on using the meat. You can keep fresh leftover beef in the refrigerator for up to 3 days or freeze it for up to 6 months if you don’t plan on using it within that time. Then, reheat it in the microwave.

To freeze, divide the meat into individual portions and wrap them in plastic wrap. Then, place the wrapped pieces into freezer bags and seal the bags shut.

Keeping the meat fresh and preventing freezer burn will preserve the brisket and keep it fresh until you want to use it.

How long can brisket be kept refrigerated?

The Brisket’s shelf life depends on a few factors, such as the best-by date and how you store it. In the fridge, it can stay fresh for up to 3 days.

How long can you freeze brisket?

Freezing the brisket will help keep it fresh for up to 12 months.